Podcast/FxFriend Podcast/EP10 Risk-Reward vs Win Rate: Why Winning Often Won't Grow Your Account
Episode 10Trading Strategies

EP10 Risk-Reward vs Win Rate: Why Winning Often Won't Grow Your Account

Winning rock-paper-scissors 9 out of 10 times doesn't help if the single loss means paying for the whole Thai BBQ dinner. FxFriend Podcast EP10 breaks down why a high Win Rate doesn't mean your account grows, showing how to calculate Expectancy alongside Risk-Reward Ratio (RR).

November 19, 20267 min0 plays0 views

EP10 Risk-Reward vs Win Rate: Why Winning Often Won't Grow Your Account

0:000:00

Show Notes

▶️ Watch the video version on YouTube: https://youtu.be/ULiLv4LrEOs

Winning rock-paper-scissors 9 out of 10 times doesn't help if the single loss means you have to pay for the whole Thai BBQ dinner. In this episode, we explain why a high Win Rate doesn't automatically grow your account. You need to look at it together with Risk-Reward Ratio (RR) and calculate your Expectancy, complete with a comparison table between 75% and 35% Win Rate systems, breakeven win rates, the dangerous trap of moving your Stop Loss, and 5 tips to balance your strategy.

Timestamps

  • 00:00 Intro: Winning rock-paper-scissors 9 out of 10 times... but you get stuck with the bill
  • 00:14 Getting started: Even with zero fees, your system might not make money
  • 00:33 1 · Win Rate and the "winning often" trap
  • 01:18 2 · Risk-Reward Ratio (RR)
  • 01:41 3 · Expectancy: System A (75%) vs System B (35%)
  • 02:33 Breakeven Win Rate
  • 02:52 The Trap: Moving Stop Loss away + how costs eat up low-profit systems
  • 03:30 5 ways to rebalance your system
  • 03:56 Why our brains are obsessed with Win Rate
  • 04:09 Host's Take: Win Rate is a feeling, Expectancy is real money
  • 04:25 Summary
  • 04:39 Homework (with a brain teaser) and next episode preview

System Comparison Table (Article Example)

SystemWin RateRRExpectancy per Trade
A (High Win Rate)75%1:0.5(0.75×0.5) − (0.25×1) = 0.125
B (Low Win Rate)35%1:3(0.35×3) − (0.65×1) = 0.40

Breakeven Win Rate = 1 ÷ (1 + RR)

  • RR 1:1 → Need 50% Win Rate
  • RR 1:2 → Win around 33% to break even
  • RR 1:0.5 → Need almost 67% Win Rate

5 Tips to Balance Your Trading System

  1. Log every single trade along with your actual RR
  2. Don't set Take Profit targets too close just to chase a high Win Rate · Calculate your breakeven Win Rate first
  3. Deduct costs (spread, commission, slippage) before calculating RR
  4. Never move your Stop Loss further away from price
  5. Backtest across various market conditions

Homework (No Deposit Required)

If you have trading history: Review your last 20 trades. Calculate your Win Rate, average winning trade vs average losing trade, and calculate your Expectancy. · If you don't have trading history: Try this riddle—You win 6 trades making $50 each, and lose 4 trades losing $100 each. You won more trades than you lost, but did your account balance go up or down?

Read Full Article & Related Links

This content is for risk management education only and does not constitute investment advice. Numbers used are for illustrative purposes. Trading Forex, Gold, and Crypto carries high risk.

Transcript
You play rock-paper-scissors with your friend ten times win nine of them ten baht per round. But for the round you lose the agreement was that the loser pays for Thai BBQ for the whole table winning nine out of ten but that night, you’re the one paying the bill. Hello, this is FxFriend Podcast, episode 10 RR and Win Rate why you win often, but your portfolio doesn't grow. Last episode we talked about hidden costs today we’re going deeper even if there were zero fees your system still might not make money if you’re looking at the wrong numbers. Part one Win Rate. Win Rate is the proportion of winning trades compared to total trades beginners love looking at this first because seeing lots of green trades feels good but Win Rate tells you nothing about how much you win per trade or how much you lose per trade. Imagine a trader who sets a very tight profit target of just half to one percent but sets a wide Stop Loss of three to four percent because they’re afraid of price spikes their Win Rate might be as high as seventy-five percent but the day a single Stop Loss hits five or six trades worth of accumulated profit vanish in a single trade. It’s like a soccer player who completes every short pass beautiful stats but doesn't score a single goal all game and loses three to zero. Part two RR or Risk Reward. RR is the ratio between the risk you accept and the reward you expect setting a Stop Loss of one hundred dollars and a profit target of three hundred that’s an RR of one to three risking one part to gain three parts we already discussed how to calculate position size back in episode three. Part three the one that tells the truth is Expectancy. Expectancy is the expected value per trade the rough formula is Win Rate multiplied by RR minus the loss rate multiplied by one. Let's compare two systems System A wins seventy-five percent, but its RR is only one to half calculating that gives zero point one two five System B wins only thirty-five percent, but its RR is one to three giving zero point four. The system that loses almost two-thirds of the time actually makes almost three times more money. It’s like two fishermen the first catches tiny minnows every ten minutes, looking very busy all day the second sits quietly all morning, catching nothing but in the afternoon catches one big fish selling it for more than the first fisherman's entire bucket of minnows. Another key number to know break-even Win Rate an RR of one to one requires a fifty percent win rate just to break even an RR of one to two only needs about thirty-three percent to break even but an RR of one to half requires nearly sixty-seven percent every single month, with no room for error. Now, the most common trap moving your Stop Loss away because you don't want that trade to lose your statistical Win Rate looks great but in reality, you're just hoarding risk, waiting for the day it explodes just like we discussed in the Martingale episode. It’s like putting off a dentist appointment repeatedly because you don't want the pain in the end, you don't just get a filling you need a root canal. Another thing systems that make tiny profits per trade are the easiest targets for hidden costs spread, commissions, slippage the more frequently you trade just to chase Win Rate the faster costs add up some systems look positive on paper but turn negative after real costs, just like we discussed in the last episode. Now, here's how to balance your system one, record every trade, not just wins or losses, but log the actual RR as well two, don't set profit targets too close just to chase Win Rate calculate your break-even Win Rate first three, deduct costs before calculating RR four, never move your Stop Loss away from price and five, backtest your system across various market conditions, not just when the market is friendly. So why are we so addicted to Win Rate? Because the human brain loves the feeling of winning and it always remembers winning trades much more clearly than losing ones if you don't keep a log your memory becomes a salesman hyping up your own system unrealistically. My personal take. Win Rate is emotion Expectancy is money I prefer losing often but losing small over winning often but losing big but the best system is the one you can actually execute on every trade, not the prettiest one on paper. Today's recap Win Rate tells you how often you win, but not the size RR tells you how many parts you target for every one part risked Expectancy tells you the truth about whether the system makes money and never move your Stop Loss away. Homework for this episode, no deposit required. If you have a trading history, open your last twenty trades find three numbers Win Rate average profit of winning trades versus average loss of losing trades then try calculating Expectancy if you don't have a history yet try this problem win six trades of fifty dollars each lose four trades of one hundred dollars each you won more than you lost but add it up to see if your account goes up or down if you get a negative number you understand this episode now. Next episode the enemy inside our own heads FOMO and Revenge Trading days when the plan is good, but the mindset breaks. The full article with system comparison tables is in the show notes. This is FxFriend Podcast the friend who warns you before it hurts see you next episode.

Related Episodes